Please Support Us In the Most Meaningless Way of AllAugust 1st, 2012
Most nonprofits are still struggling to get back to their pre-recession levels of support. While some have made it through unscathed, it hasn’t been easy. They can tell you that commitment to mission and donors is essential.
This is why I get so frustrated when I see corporations taking advantage of the nonprofits that are having more difficulties by offering funds to them in various “contests” that serve only as publicity stunts for the companies, really.
What started out as a national trend has already expanded to local companies, making the same types of offers to the very small – and desperate – local nonprofits as well.
These set ups remind me of various “Are you in debt?” commercials, offering distressed consumers options they might not otherwise take for high interest loans, credit cards, etc. In other words, easy money.
A nonprofit that hasn’t yet made its goal has a pot of gold dangled in front of its eyes, and “all it has to do” is chant the chosen mantra of the corporation of the month that is throwing this particular bone into the pit of desperation.
Of course, it’s not enough that the nonprofit itself blather the company slogan on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Tumblr, GooglePlus, and anywhere, everywhere else that the company is tracking it. No, the organization must use all available venues to reach its constituents to nag, beg and cajole them to do the same . . . for the good of the organization(?)
Never mind that the bank, life insurance company, software developer, etc. has nothing whatever to do with the mission of the organization.
“Please, PLEASE text/post ‘Get 2 Free Boxes of Checks with a Bank ABC Checking Account!’ on every channel – once a day, until [deadline], so we can win the $XX,000!”
Like all scams, the easy money only appears easy. Not only does staff become consumed with constant reminders to all supporters, then someone has to keep track of where the organization stands each day of the contest. (“We’ve fallen to 2nd place! Please remember to keep posting daily!”)
The saturation point of supporters will likely cost you in terms of loyalty down the road, even if your organization does win the contest, not to mention the fact that you’ve disconnected your supporters substantially from your mission. A great deal will have to be rebuilt in the future.
And, if you plan on “winning” such contests as an ongoing part of your budget, both your staff and supporters will become exhausted and burned out, which means your churn rate will go through the roof. Additionally, you’ll support the corporate notion that this is an acceptable way to support nonprofits, rather than directly via grants and sponsorships. (Bad idea.)
Research has shown that the best way to gain long term support for your organization is through telling a compelling story about what you do by who benefits from your work.
Chanting some company slogan couldn’t be much farther off point than this, and is probably working to alienate your supporters more than just about any other activity you could be doing, short of a scandal.
The next time you’re tempted to participate in an easy money scheme, think about the story it tells. If it doesn’t further your mission, toss it aside. You’re wasting time and money pursuing it, not to mention constituent loyalty.
Keep the base of the pyramid strong
Tags: annual giving, campaign, contest, corporate giving, corporations, donor, donors, Facebook, fund raising, fundraising, GooglePlus, LinkedIn, marketing, mission, non profit, non profits, nonprofit, nonprofits, online fund raising, online fundraising, publicity, publicity stunt, scam, social media, social networking, SOFII, storytelling, Tumblr, Twitter