There are now many more tools in the toolbox when it comes to contacting constituents, but email is still a valuable one – and definitely one of the most profitable in terms of ROI when soliciting, as well as newsletters, updates, etc.
Some nonprofits have better luck than others raising funds or engaging their followers online, however. Further scrutiny into their methodologies, combined with available research on the topic, often yields insight which demonstrates that various changes in campaign strategies can bolster – sometimes significantly – online income.
First, remember that email is a more personal and less formal way of communicating than direct mail. While your language may not be exactly slang, it shouldn’t read like an engraved invitation that comes in the mail, either. Although your type of communication always depends upon your organization and audience, most people feel comfortable being addressed by their first name in an email. Other nonprofits leave off the “Dear Curtis” and any signature at all and simply write the message, recognizing the need and expectation that this is a casual mode of communication.
A disturbing trend these days is the automation of so many email systems to the point that the [From] name is listed as [NoReply@nonprofit.org]. (click to enlarge) Nothing screams “form letter” louder than this! Not only has this sender name guaranteed a lower open and readership rate, but regardless of how much effort you have put into carefully crafting your personal message, many recipients will have concluded that your organization doesn’t really care, since it couldn’t bother to have an actual person send it . . . or receive a reply. Nearly the same conclusion is reached for the similar email sent by one person, who opens with “From the desk of [important person].” This translates as, “You weren’t significant enough for me to take the time to write to you myself, but won’t you send us money?”
Brevity is essential. Indeed, tweets and texting make emails look too lengthy these days, so get to the point as quickly as possible. Embedded links are ideal for providing additional documentation, videos, registration forms, etc., but yammering on is the quickest way to drive a recipient to the [delete] button.
For an enewsletter, not only are more of your articles likely to get read if each of them has a short summary, followed by a link to read it in full, but your analytics will then show which of the articles was more often read in full. If each article is completely written out, the amount of scrolling required to get the final few will result in them being read less often, due to positioning rather than content, leaving you with tainted data.
When embedding hyperlinks in various email communications, take care to link significant text, rather than something obvious yet meaningless, such as “click here.” Soon, your entire email can become riddled with them, rendering it more confusing than helpful.
Using photos in emails can help to sell your point even further, but don’t assume that everyone can view the pictures you’ve inserted. To make sure that both sets of recipients receive your overall message, be certain that photos are only part of the message rather than the entire email. Also, since many people view emails in a preview pane, test yours prior to sending: Can you see any text in the preview pane, without opening it entirely? Another important precaution when using pictures is to place text behind the picture, so that it will appear when the photo doesn’t.
Many organizations are tracking how many visitors come to their site via mobile and creating a different layout that adjusts for that viewing. How does your email look when viewed on a handheld device? Is it any better when in a landscape position? Do you test sending and receiving emails to different email clients and devices prior to sending?
Would you change your text, links or [Donate] button if you viewed your email on a handheld?
Another way to help ensure deliverability is to check your spam score. Certain words – and even punctuation – used in the body of the email, or subject line, will increase your score and get your message deleted from various filters. Test your message first for any red flags and boost your number of emails received.
Finally, keep your subscription list as accurate as possible (and in compliance with the CAN-SPAM Act) by adding a footer to each and every email that asks the recipient about the validity of their subscription. Go a step further than providing an [unsubscribe] link, however, and you’ll retain more people than you otherwise would.
Too many nonprofits only offer [unsubscribe] as an option and don’t consider the portion of their constituency that are changing jobs, or simply wish to receive messages at a different email address. The better option to offer is [update my subscription].
When the constituent selects this option, s/he can choose [unsubscribe], but if they simply wish to change to a different email, this can still be done in one step. If your form collects additional information, such as title, phone, etc., this can also be done in the same place. Later, if your organization sends multiple newsletters or communications, the subscription form can be segmented: Perhaps I wish to subscribe to the food pantry enewsletter, but not the “Meals on Wheels” enewsletter, and I also want to mark myself “Do Not Solicit by phone.”
If I can do this and update my email in one step, I’m more likely to provide my preferences and stay connected. On the other hand, if I only have the option of [unsubscribe] with this email, then I have to go the home page and sign up all over again with a new email and enter my various preferences . . . I’m more likely to remove myself altogether and be done with it.
When viewing details such as these, it becomes clearer how paying more attention – or not – to individuals’ needs and preferences can make a significant difference with email marketing. Some studies have said that email doesn’t yet have the return that direct mail does, but I would counter that most nonprofits spend much more time and effort, catering to the specific demands of the donor when soliciting by mail.
I daresay that when the same painstaking detail is invested into email campaigns, as well as follow through, we will see the industry as a whole yield a significant rise in email income and overall engagement.
Keep the base of the pyramid strong